May 11, 2021

Saudi court slams jail term to iconic female activist despite global criticism

5 min read

Screenshot from a France24 YouTube video showing Saudi activist Loujain al-Hathloul.
Prominent Saudi human rights defender Loujain al-Hathloul, whose detention since 2018 had stoked global criticism, was sentenced to nearly six years in prison on December 28 by the kingdom’s notorious terrorism court in an alarming development to her years-long fight for freedom.
According to her sister, Lina, Loujain should be released by March 2021, having already served the majority of her sentence as pre-trial detention, as she shares in a tweet:

BREAKING : Today @LoujainHathloul was sentenced to-5 years and 8 months in prison- A suspension of 2 years and 10 months in addition to the time already served (since May 2018) which would see her release in approximately two months.-5 years travel banNote: 👇🏽
— Lina Alhathloul لينا الهذلول (@LinaAlhathloul) December 28, 2020
Lina also mentioned in another tweet that her sister Loujain “cried when she heard the sentence today”, and that she “will appeal the sentence and ask for another investigation regarding torture”.
According to local press citing the court’s ruling, 31-year-old Loujain was found guilty of “committing acts criminalized under Article 43 of the Law on Combating Terrorism Crimes“, including engaging with foreign, hostile entities, and using the internet to serve and support an external agenda inside the kingdom, with the aim of harming public order. 
Loujain’s sentence comes after a rushed trial deemed flawed by international human rights groups. Although the sentence is down from the maximum jail term of up to 20 years which the public prosecutor demanded on December 17, it is expected to draw added condemnation of the kingdom which is already grappling with a grim record of human rights violations, both within its territories and beyond. 
Loujain has been at the forefront of campaigns demanding women’s right to drive and is a leading figure in the calls to put an end to the male guardianship system which treats Saudi women as second-class citizens.
Mary Lawlor, the United Nations Special Rapporteur on Human Rights Defenders, tweeted:

I’m receiving disturbing reports that #Saudi WHRD Loujain Al Hathloul has been convicted & given a prison sentence by an anti-terrorism court. She should be immediately released. Defending human rights is not terrorism @patrickwintour @jongambrellAP @NiAolainF @sebusher pic.twitter.com/uH2xTRvFMM
— Mary Lawlor UN Special Rapporteur HRDs (@MaryLawlorhrds) December 28, 2020
Human Rights Watch’s Executive Director Kenneth Roth reacted by saying:

The Saudi government denies Loujain al-Hathoul was prosecuted for campaigning for women’s right to drive “but instead for mounting a campaign to undermine the royal family.” That’s because the Saudi crown prince views any political activism as a threat. https://t.co/RlJV1m2ugo pic.twitter.com/UY1K5dWhmb
— Kenneth Roth (@KenRoth) December 28, 2020
Observers have opined that the shorter sentence is a reflection of the anticipated changes in leadership in Washington DC. Donald Trump’s administration remains a staunch supporter of Saudi’s de facto ruler Crown Prince Mohamed bin Salman, who is commonly known by his initials – MBS, and has turned a blind eye to the harrowing human rights record that quickly became associated with the prince.

Our Washpost edtorial says the conviction of Loujain al Hathloul is a travesty–and also a sign that international pressure on MBS can work. @LinaAlhathloul https://t.co/8UUGOZLs4U
— Jackson Diehl (@JacksonDiehl) December 28, 2020
US president-elect Joe Biden has stated his administration will be taking a less lenient position towards Riyadh’s human rights abuses, a stand which was reiterated following Loujain’s sentence by his National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan:

Saudi Arabia’s sentencing of Loujain al-Hathloul for simply exercising her universal rights is unjust and troubling. As we have said, the Biden-Harris administration will stand up against human rights violations wherever they occur.
— Jake Sullivan (@jakejsullivan) December 28, 2020
In May 2018, Loujain was kidnapped in the United Arab Emirates and, along with other female activists, was detained for months before the coming into effect of a breakthrough royal decree, which they had long campaigned for, that allowed women to drive. After her extradition to the Saudi kingdom, Hathloul remained in pre-trial detention, with alleged periods of solitary confinement, a suspension of family visits, and torture. She had resorted to staging a hunger strike in order to see her family.
It was only on 24 November that her family was told that her long-delayed trial was to begin the following day, giving her parents, who are her legal representatives, only one day to prepare. On November 25, Loujain’s case was referred from criminal court to the Specialised Criminal Court on accusations of harming national security through cooperating with foreign entities.

Transferring @LoujainHathloul ‘s case to the “Terrorism” court doesn’t make her a terrorist. It exposes though the brutality & hypocrisy of #Saudi authorities that instrumentalise “women empowerment” to whitewash their image, while prosecuting women activists under sham charges. https://t.co/zTsl2162hp
— Amnesty Gulf (@amnestygulf) November 25, 2020
Since it began a month ago, the trial had garnered a lot of criticism.

I am concerned that Saudi Arabia is seeking the maximum jail sentence for women’s rights activist Loujain al-Hathloul. She, as well as the other activists, should be immediately and unconditionally released, and all charges against them dropped.
— U.S. Senate Foreign Relations Committee (@SenateForeign) December 17, 2020
Having become a symbol for political prisoners in the oil-rich kingdom, Hathloul’s incarceration had cast global doubt over the sincerity of Riyadh’s rapid social, cultural and economic reforms, led by MBS. In fact, global solidarity with Hathloul and her female colleagues, along with the brutal murder of journalist Jamal Khashoggi which is believed to have been ordered by MBS, and the Saudi role in the humanitarian crisis in Yemen, have all tarnished the young prince’s image and increased pressure on Riyadh’s Western allies to re-evaluate ties with the kingdom.
Director of Advocacy at @BIRDBahrain_ Sayed Ahmed AlWadaei tweeted:

International condemnation of #FreeLoujain began with #Canada & #Germany taking the lead:
Germany: https://t.co/z0CusQijVt
Canada: https://t.co/SuDNC4YOwC
More countries expected to follow… pic.twitter.com/3GumGx8BdS
— Sayed Ahmed AlWadaei (@SAlwadaei) December 28, 2020
Hathloul had told her family she was subjected to electric shocks, whippings, and sexual harassment, and her family also alleges that that she was offered freedom if she agreed to say she was not tortured.

Loujain was on a hunger strike for 2 weeks (started Oct 26) during which she was checked on regularly. After the 2 weeks they began waking her up every 2hours at night. It exhausted her psychologically, she said she had horrible nightmares and therefore broke her hunger strike. https://t.co/7iRed0vpJl
— Lina Alhathloul لينا الهذلول (@LinaAlhathloul) November 25, 2020
Calls for a transparent and unbiased investigation into Hathloul’s claim of abuse and torture have fallen on deaf ears. The judge’s denial of Loujain’s claims of torture triggered a hashtag on Twitter last week that brought together sympathizers who defended her claim.

I like this hashtag which translates to: Loujain Is No Liar #لجين_لاتكذب#LoujainAlHathloul and jailed women rights activist are confronting ruthless and brutal jailer. No secret about that.
— Fadi Al-Qadi (@fqadi) December 23, 2020
Another female Saudi activist, Mayaa al-Zahrani received the same sentence as Loujain’s.

Today #SaudiArabia’s SCC (terrorism court) also sentenced human rights defender Mayaa al-Zahrani to 5 years and 8 months in prison, with 2 years and 10 months suspended, exactly the same as for @LoujainHathloul. pic.twitter.com/JYiT27WnFZ
— ALQST for Human Rights (@ALQST_En) December 28, 2020